I’ve lived my entire life surrounded by people who prided themselves on being ‘brutally honest’. While everyone seemed to value the same kind of honesty, honesty that was absent of compassion or consideration for the receiver, I was left licking wounds. I knew I didn’t share the same values. Sometimes, especially when it comes from the people closest to you, the brutality could go unnoticed and normalized. How do we know when someone’s honesty isn’t helpful, but hurtful?
1. Why are they being honest?
Honesty, above all else, should be goal-oriented. Honesty should support actions or changes that resolve a problem or contribute to one’s growth. However, when honesty becomes ego-driven, we enter harmful territory. What is meant to be helpful quickly becomes an attempt to feel superior or to project their own ideas and frustrations onto the receiver. Let’s say you’re in a toxic relationship and you’re asking advice from a friend:
Helpful: You deserve better.
Harmful: If you stay, you’re allowing them to hurt you.
2. There’s no actionable advice.
We all have to accept hard truths from time to time. Odds are you have, and the last time probably won’t be the last time. But the support you have when those occasions arise will make a difference in how you manage the discomfort. If they’re not suggesting or helping you brainstorm a path forward or an attainable solution, the honesty isn’t helpful.
Helpful: Offers a critique, followed by encouragement and suggestions for improvement.
Harmful: It is a “take it or leave it” insult disguised as the truth, leaving you feeling stuck and bad about yourself.
3. Consider the timing and place.
Honesty, even without brutality, is never appropriate or well-received when you’re vulnerable. Sometimes, when the truth comes out, and it’s heavy, we don’t need advice; we just need support and comfort. And this definitely does not need to happen in front of an audience. Honesty shouldn’t feel like being “called out” in front of a crowd.
Helpful: Empathetic about your current condition. Is this something you need to hear right now?
Harmful: Sharing a harsh truth when you’re already struggling, or calling you out in front of an audience, is a power move, not an attempt at being helpful.
There’s one thing I’ve noticed about people who prefer brutality when being honest: they lack nuance. Honesty is used as a blunt-force object because it ignores the complexity of a situation. It’s used to avoid the intellectual and emotional effort required to make sense of what they’ve already made sense of. That does not mean their struggles need to be yours. Surround yourself with good people who empower you, and the rest will become noise.
Featured image via LEPTA STUDIO on Pexels
You articulated this subject very well. I really like the comment comparisons you did using the categories of “helpful” versus “harmful.” I know someone who always uses brutal honesty to project his own frustrations and I wish that I could have shared your thoughtful analysis with him a long time ago.
That honest communication in relationships often needs support, structure, and understanding, not just blunt truth. That’s why resources like Family Therapy for Addiction & Mental Health in Springfield, MA at New Growth Recovery matter so much: they help families learn how to speak truth in ways that heal and build connection rather than unknowingly wound one another. Honest feedback isn’t the problem – it’s when it’s offered without support, understanding, or a path toward growth https://www.newgrowthrecovery.com/services/addiction-counseling-therapy-springfield-ma/family-therapy